-
Merge branch 'fair-usage-of-shared-runners' into 'master' · 919e3ed2Stan Hu authored
Fair usage of Shared Runners ## What does this MR do? Introduces a fair usage scheduler for shared runners. It tries to assign builds to shared runner from projects that have the lowest number of builds currently running on shared runners. **Example 1**: ``` We have following builds in queue: build 1 for project 1 build 2 for project 1 build 3 for project 1 build 4 for project 2 build 5 for project 2 build 6 for project 3 With the new algorithm we will assign builds in following order: - We choose build 1, because project 1 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We choose build 4, because project 2 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We choose build 6, because project 3 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We choose build 2, because project 1 as other it runs 1 build, - We choose build 5, because project 2 runs 1 build, where project 1 runs 2 builds now, - We choose build 3, because project 1 and runs 2 builds. ``` **Example 2**: ``` We have following builds in queue: build 1 for project 1 build 2 for project 1 build 3 for project 1 build 4 for project 2 build 5 for project 2 build 6 for project 3 With the new algorithm we will assign builds in following order: - We choose build 1, because project 1 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We finish build 1, - We choose build 2, because project 1 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We choose build 4, because project 2 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We finish build 4, - We choose build 5, because project 2 doesn't run currently any builds and has the lowest build number from projects that doesn't run builds, - We choose build 6, because project 3 doesn't run currently any builds, - We choose build 3, because project 1, 2 and 3 runs exactly one build now, ``` ## Why was this MR needed? Currently, we are scheduling builds using FIFO. This is catastrophic if there are projects that create a 100-300 jobs, this basically eats most of available shared runners. ## Performance All this logic is implemented with the help of SQL queries, because this is the fastest way to process 1k-2k pending builds in queue. It's not the fastest SQL query, because it sorts based on number of running_builds, and this forces to calculate a number of running builds for all dependent projects. However, since we have one/two shared runners that asks every few seconds for builds this should have minimal impact on DB performance. ``` explain analyze SELECT "ci_builds".* FROM "ci_builds" JOIN (SELECT "ci_builds"."gl_project_id", count(case when status = 'running' AND runner_id = (SELECT "ci_runners"."id" FROM "ci_runners" WHERE "ci_runners"."is_shared" = 't') then 1 end) as running_builds FROM "ci_builds" INNER JOIN "projects" ON "projects"."id" = "ci_builds"."gl_project_id" AND "projects"."pending_delete" = 'f' WHERE "ci_builds"."type" IN ('Ci::Build') AND "ci_builds"."status" IN ('running', 'pending') AND "projects"."builds_enabled" = 't' AND "projects"."shared_runners_enabled" = 't' GROUP BY "ci_builds"."gl_project_id") AS projects ON ci_builds.gl_project_id=projects.gl_project_id WHERE "ci_builds"."type" IN ('Ci::Build') AND "ci_builds"."status" = 'pending' AND "ci_builds"."runner_id" IS NULL ORDER BY projects.running_builds ASC, ci_builds.id ASC; QUERY PLAN -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- Sort (cost=64777.28..64777.29 rows=1 width=1010) (actual time=301.794..302.535 rows=1537 loops=1) Sort Key: (count(CASE WHEN (((public.ci_builds.status)::text = 'running'::text) AND (public.ci_builds.runner_id = $0)) THEN 1 ELSE NULL::integer END)), public.ci _builds.id Sort Method: quicksort Memory: 1423kB -> Nested Loop (cost=63279.78..64777.27 rows=1 width=1010) (actual time=66.384..298.724 rows=1537 loops=1) -> HashAggregate (cost=63177.15..63177.30 rows=15 width=15) (actual time=65.641..65.851 rows=187 loops=1) InitPlan 1 (returns $0) -> Seq Scan on ci_runners (cost=0.00..26963.66 rows=1 width=4) (actual time=1.145..34.381 rows=1 loops=1) Filter: is_shared Rows Removed by Filter: 6965 -> Nested Loop (cost=0.00..36186.34 rows=2715 width=15) (actual time=0.065..29.717 rows=1710 loops=1) -> Index Scan using index_ci_builds_on_status on ci_builds (cost=0.00..8913.95 rows=3577 width=15) (actual time=0.051..12.012 rows=2583 loops =1) Index Cond: ((status)::text = ANY ('{running,pending}'::text[])) Filter: ((type)::text = 'Ci::Build'::text) Rows Removed by Filter: 1219 -> Index Scan using projects_pkey on projects (cost=0.00..7.61 rows=1 width=4) (actual time=0.003..0.004 rows=1 loops=2583) Index Cond: (id = public.ci_builds.gl_project_id) Filter: ((NOT pending_delete) AND builds_enabled AND shared_runners_enabled) Rows Removed by Filter: 0 -> Bitmap Heap Scan on ci_builds (cost=102.63..106.64 rows=1 width=1002) (actual time=1.216..1.231 rows=8 loops=187) Recheck Cond: ((gl_project_id = public.ci_builds.gl_project_id) AND ((status)::text = 'pending'::text)) Filter: ((runner_id IS NULL) AND ((type)::text = 'Ci::Build'::text)) -> BitmapAnd (cost=102.63..102.63 rows=1 width=0) (actual time=1.201..1.201 rows=0 loops=187) -> Bitmap Index Scan on index_ci_builds_on_gl_project_id (cost=0.00..10.52 rows=241 width=0) (actual time=0.406..0.406 rows=1944 loops=187) Index Cond: (gl_project_id = public.ci_builds.gl_project_id) -> Bitmap Index Scan on index_ci_builds_on_status (cost=0.00..91.78 rows=3089 width=0) (actual time=0.652..0.652 rows=3362 loops=187) Index Cond: ((status)::text = 'pending'::text) Total runtime: 303.832 ms ``` ## Specific runners It doesn't affect the specific runners which still serve builds FIFO. @stanhu @markpundsack @yorickpeterse What do you think? See merge request !4634
919e3ed2
Name |
Last commit
|
Last update |
---|---|---|
.github | Loading commit data... | |
app | Loading commit data... | |
bin | Loading commit data... | |
builds | Loading commit data... | |
config | Loading commit data... | |
db | Loading commit data... | |
doc | Loading commit data... | |
docker | Loading commit data... | |
features | Loading commit data... | |
fixtures/emojis | Loading commit data... | |
generator_templates/active_record/migration | Loading commit data... | |
lib | Loading commit data... | |
log | Loading commit data... | |
public | Loading commit data... | |
scripts | Loading commit data... | |
shared | Loading commit data... | |
spec | Loading commit data... | |
tmp | Loading commit data... | |
vendor | Loading commit data... | |
.csscomb.json | Loading commit data... | |
.flayignore | Loading commit data... | |
.foreman | Loading commit data... | |
.gitattributes | Loading commit data... | |
.gitignore | Loading commit data... | |
.gitlab-ci.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.hound.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.pkgr.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.rspec | Loading commit data... | |
.rubocop.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.ruby-version | Loading commit data... | |
.scss-lint.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.simplecov | Loading commit data... | |
.teatro.yml | Loading commit data... | |
.vagrant_enabled | Loading commit data... | |
CHANGELOG | Loading commit data... | |
CONTRIBUTING.md | Loading commit data... | |
GITLAB_SHELL_VERSION | Loading commit data... | |
GITLAB_WORKHORSE_VERSION | Loading commit data... | |
Gemfile | Loading commit data... | |
Gemfile.lock | Loading commit data... | |
LICENSE | Loading commit data... | |
MAINTENANCE.md | Loading commit data... | |
PROCESS.md | Loading commit data... | |
Procfile | Loading commit data... | |
README.md | Loading commit data... | |
Rakefile | Loading commit data... | |
VERSION | Loading commit data... | |
config.ru | Loading commit data... | |
doc_styleguide.md | Loading commit data... | |
docker-compose.yml | Loading commit data... |